Exploring the Authenticity of Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza: Can You Find the Real Deal Outside of Chicago?

Chicago-style deep dish pizza is a culinary icon, a dish that has become synonymous with the Windy City itself. Its thick, buttery crust, chunky tomato sauce, and generous layers of cheese set it apart from other pizza styles. But can you find an authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza outside of Chicago? The answer is both yes and no. While there are pizzerias outside of Chicago that strive to replicate the authentic deep dish experience, there are certain elements that are difficult to replicate. Let’s delve deeper into this topic.

What Makes a Pizza Chicago-Style?

Chicago-style deep dish pizza is characterized by its unique construction. Unlike traditional pizzas, the cheese goes on the bottom, followed by the toppings, and finally, the sauce. The crust is thick and buttery, often compared to a pie crust, and the pizza itself is baked in a deep, round pan, giving it its distinctive deep-dish shape. The result is a pizza that is hearty, rich, and incredibly satisfying.

Can You Find Authentic Chicago-Style Pizza Outside of Chicago?

There are certainly pizzerias outside of Chicago that offer deep-dish pizzas on their menus. Some of these establishments are even run by Chicago natives who have brought their recipes with them. However, whether these pizzas can be considered truly authentic is a matter of debate. There are certain elements of the Chicago-style pizza experience that are difficult to replicate outside of the city.

What Makes the Authenticity Difficult to Replicate?

Firstly, there’s the water. Many Chicago pizzaiolos swear by the city’s tap water, claiming it gives the dough its unique texture and flavor. While this may sound like a minor detail, anyone who’s ever baked bread knows that the water can make a big difference.

Secondly, there’s the oven. Chicago-style pizzas are typically baked in old, well-seasoned ovens that have been used for decades. These ovens have a certain character that’s difficult to replicate in a newer oven.

Finally, there’s the atmosphere. Eating a deep-dish pizza in a bustling Chicago pizzeria, surrounded by the city’s unique energy and charm, is an experience in itself. While you can certainly enjoy a deep-dish pizza outside of Chicago, it’s just not quite the same.


So, can you find authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza outside of Chicago? Technically, yes. But will it be exactly the same as what you’d get in the Windy City? Probably not. However, that doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy a delicious deep-dish pizza wherever you are. After all, the most important thing is that it tastes good to you.